Error message

Notice: Undefined index: und in citation_doi_content() (line 88 of /home/fulltxt/public_html/sites/all/modules/citation/citation.module).

State of the Knowledge and Approach of School Teachers Regarding various Adolescent Health Issues from the Sangli District (Maharashtra), India: An Urban-Rural Difference

Baliram, Manohar, and Bhimrao: State of the Knowledge and Approach of School Teachers Regarding various Adolescent Health Issues from the Sangli District (Maharashtra), India: An Urban-Rural Difference

Authors

INTRODUCTION

The word adolescence is derived from Latin word, adolescere meaning “growing to maturity”.1 Adolescence is an important phase comprising of psychological, physical and social change, which results in the development of new behaviours, thinking and outlook. These changes play an important part in adult life.2 Adolescents frequently suffer from problems like substance abuse, STIs, HIV/AIDS, psychological problems and reproductive health issues.3 These problems can have lifelong implications.4 However proper medical advice are rarely sought due to barriers like stigma attached to these problems, lack of availability, costs, lack of knowledge, anxiety about confidentiality, gender bias, social bias, etc.5,6 Hence we have to go beyond health specialists to meet their needs.

School-based interventions can lead to reduced substance misuse, violence, and other antisocial behaviours in adolescents.7 It is recommended to incorporate health issues in the curriculum.8 Thus, involvement of teachers can prove of great importance in maintaining adolescent health.

But according to some researchers the knowledge of school teachers regarding adolescent health is lacking.9 Similarly, the data regarding their active involvement in adolescent health is inadequate. Hence the current study was planned with the aim to assess involvement of school teachers in the adolescent health.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

It was a cross-sectional study conducted among school teachers from the secondary schools of Sangli district (Maharashtra) India; during August-2015 to March-2016. In a previous such Indian study, partial knowledge regarding adolescent health was observed in 55.2% teachers.9 Based on those findings calculated sample size (prevalence, p=55.2% i.e. 0.552, q=1-p, α=0.05, allowable error, d=5% and applying formula Zα2pq/d2) was 380. Assuming losses due to incomplete questionnaires at 15%, the sample size was adjusted to 437 ≅ 450. The observed ratio urban: rural teachers was roughly 1:4, hence it was decided to include minimum 90 and 360 teachers from urban and rural area respectively. It was observed that, each school had at least ten teachers. So, we decided to randomly select 10 urban and 36 rural schools. Two stage sampling was used for the data collection. Stratified random sampling was used for the first stage. Sangli district was divided in two strata, urban & rural. Schools in each stratum were listed and randomly selected. Second stage was convenience sampling i.e. all the teachers in the selected school were invited for participation. Seven hundred forty-eight teachers from the selected schools participated in the study. Voluntary informed consent was the selection criteria. The due ethical and administrative permissions were obtained for the study.

The study tool was self-administered, pre-tested questionnaire developed with the help of specialists from the field, experienced faculty and published literature.10,11,12,13 A pilot study was conducted; the questionnaire was modified and finalized after it. The data from the pilot study was not included in the final analysis. The questionnaire consisted of socio-demographic factors and a scale for assessing their involvement in the adolescent health. The scale had three subscales; each related to awareness, attitude and practices regarding adolescent health. The awareness subscale measured understanding of the teachers regarding mental health issues and behavioural problems in adolescents. The attitude subscale primarily enquired about their attitude towards adolescent reproductive health problems. The practices subscales probed into their actual enactment on encountering problems like mental health issues, behavioural problems and substance abuse among adolescent students. For each of subscales the desired answer was awarded one point. Total sum of points for each subscale was converted to percentage. The mean percent score of all the three subscales was calculated as a score for assessing, “Involvement of the teachers in adolescent health”. After discussion with field experts and based on observations of pilot study, it was decided that score of ≥50% to be considered as good and <50% as poor for the involvement scale and each subscale. All the three subscales had good internal consistency. The Cronbach’s a, for awareness, attitude and practices subscales was 0.57, 0.71 and 0.70 respectively. Strict confidentiality and privacy was maintained during data collection.

Percentages, descriptive statistics, Mann Whitney test and Binary logistic regression were used for statistical analysis. Analysis was done using Microsoft Excel 2003 and IBM SPSS Statistics-22 software.

RESULTS

There were seven hundred forty-eight study participants; the non-response rate was less than five percent. However, seven hundred five questionnaires were duly complete so included in the final analysis. On considering the permanent address, the participants belonging to urban and rural area were 185(26.2%) and 520(73.8%) respectively. Mean age and experience of the participants was 40.92(±8.6) and 14.69(±8.5) years respectively. Majority of the participants were males 419(59.4%) (Table 1). Seventy-five (10.6%) participants were designated teachers, while 630(89.4%) were assistant teachers. Sixty-one (8.7%) participants had undergone adolescent health training. The mean score of the involvement scale was 48.4(Std. deviation ±12.9, range 8.9-79.2); median and mode scores were 49.3 and 43.6 respectively. While the mean percent scores of subscales; awareness, attitude and practices regarding adolescent health were 48.7(Std. deviation ±17.1, range 0-95.5), 70(Std. deviation ±23, range 0-100) and 26.2(Std. deviation ±15, range 0-70.8S) respectively. The mode percent score for practices subscale was 0, while for attitude and awareness was 71.4 and 57.3 respectively (Table 2).

Mean score for Involvement scales and its subscales was higher among urban participants as compared to rural except for attitude subscale; however, differences were not statistically significant (Figure 1). Gender was associated with awareness (Mann-Whitney U= 28479.5, p=0.03) and attitude (Mann-Whitney U= 28479.5, p=0.03) subscales. The mean awareness score was higher for females (51) than males (47.1). But males had scored better on attitude subscale with the mean score of 72.1 as compared to 67.6 in females.

There was no association of designation, experience and age with involvement scale, attitude subscale and practices subscale. The awareness subscale was associated with age (Kruskal-Wallis test; chi-square= 13.3, p=0.004) and experience (Mann-Whitney U= 28479.5, p=0.03). The mean awareness score was highest at 53.4 in the age group ≤ 30 years; followed by 31-40 years (49.8), 41-50 years (46.7) and >50 years (46.2). Similarly mean awareness score was higher for those having experience ≤5 years (53.2) than >5 years (47.8). Participants undergone adolescent health training had higher mean for the involvement scale and all the subscales (Table 3).

Table 1:

Gender and permanent residence of study population

GenderPermanent AddressTotal
RuralUrban
Female19195286
66.8%33.2%100%
Male32990419
78.5%21.5%100%
Total520185705
73.8%26.2%100%
Table 2:

Scores of participants for Involvement scales and it’s subscales

Awareness regarding adolescent healthAttitude towards adolescent healthPractices regarding adolescent healthInvolvement in adolescent health
Mean48.770.226.148.4
Median51.271.426.049.3
Mode57.371.40.043.6
Std. Deviation17.123.015.012.9
Minimum0.00.00.08.9
Maximum95.5100.070.879.2
Figure 1:

Comparing mean scores of Involvement scale and it’s subscales for urban and rural teachers.

https://s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/jourdata/ijmedph/IJMedPubHea_4_183_img_001.jpg

On considering the interpretation of the scale; good score for involvement was observed in 329(46.7%) participants. Binary logistic regression was applied using Backward Wald’s method to find best predictors for involvement scales and its subscales. Age and permanent address (urban or rural) were significant predictors for awareness regarding adolescent health (Table 4 A). Awareness was better in younger (OR = 0.747) and urban (OR= 1.426) teachers as compared to older and rural teachers respectively. Most significant predictor for attitude (Table 4 B) and practices (Table 4 C) regarding adolescent health was adolescent health training and residence respectively. Participants undergone adolescent health training (OR = 2.903) and belonging to urban area (OR = 3.744) had better attitude and practices regarding adolescent health respectively. The most significant predictor for Involvement in adolescent health was the adolescent health training (OR = 2.340) (Table 4 D).

Table 3:

Comparing Mean scores of various scales with the adolescent health training

Mann-Whitney Test
Scale ScoresAdolescent health trainingMean Score (±Std. deviation)Mean RankSum of RanksMann-Whitney UWilcoxon WZP-Value
Awareness regarding adolescent healthNo48.6 (±17.1)352.1226760.519070.5226760.5-0.40.707
Yes49.5 (±17.9)362.422104.5
Attitude towards adolescent healthNo69.1 (±22.9)342.2220405.512715.5220405.5-4.60.000
Yes82.7 (±20.4)466.528459.5
Practices regarding adolescent healthNo25.8 (±14.8)347.9224055.016365.0224055.0-2.20.031
Yes29.4 (±16.2)406.724810.0
Involvement in adolescent healthNo47.8 (±12.8)344.7222009.014319.0222009.0-3.50.000
Yes53.9 (±12.9)440.326856.0
Table 4:

Binary logistic regression model depicting association of various socio-demographic factors with Involvement in adolescent scales and its subscales.

VariablesBS.E.WaldSig.OR Lower95% C.I. for OR Upper
Dependent: Awareness regarding adolescent health
AAge (>40 years)#-.292.08611.520.001.747.631.884
Permanent Address (Urban)#.355.1754.108.0431.4261.0122.011
Adolescent Training (Undergone / received training)#.537.2803.675.0551.712.9882.965
Constant-.183.422.188.665.833
Dependent: Attitude regarding adolescent health
BAdolescent Training (Undergone / received training) #1.066.5284.078.0432.9031.0328.169
Constant.525.558.884.3471.691
Dependent: Practices regarding adolescent health
CPermanent Address (Urban ) #1.320.32316.711.0003.7441.9887.050
Constant-4.592.51878.641.000.010
Dependent: Involvement in adolescent health
DAdolescent Training (Undergone / received training)#.850.2819.159.0022.3401.3494.058
Constant-1.056.31311.405.001.348

SE=Standard error, OR=Odds ratio, CI=Confidence interval

# - For categorical variables, reference category mentioned in the bracket.

Six hundred thirty-six (90.2%) and four hundred thirty (61%) participants agreed to the need of imparting sex education and orientation towards contraception respectively. Six hundred forty-nine (92%) participants supported the idea of separate health cell staffed with professionals in every school for students. Six hundred seventy-three (95.5%) participants agreed that teachers are responsible for adolescent health. While 520(73.7%) were interested in receiving comprehensive adolescent health training. Six hundred fifty-five (92.9%) and five hundred thirtyseven (76.2%) participants identified non-teaching responsibilities and lack of parents’ trust in them respectively, as major obstacles to their involvement in adolescent health.

DISCUSSION

Majority of teachers in our study had very good attitude towards adolescent health. Attitude of male teachers and teachers from rural area was better than females and teachers from urban area respectively. The overall awareness of the teachers regarding adolescent health issues was unsatisfactory. Younger teachers, female teachers and those belonging to urban area were better aware of adolescent health issues. In an Ethiopian study it was observed that teacher trainees from urban background and male trainees had better awareness regarding adolescent reproductive health.14 However that study was only regarding reproductive health as compared to multiple factors considered in our study. The practices were highly inadequate, proving that most of the teachers were unable to take required efforts regarding adolescent health issue. These were unsatisfactory among all age groups, both the genders and urban-rural area. Overall involvement of teachers had large scope for improvement. In a study conducted in the graduation colleges from Western Maharashtra (India), similar poor involvement of the teachers in the adolescent health was observed.15 In a study conducted by Cohall et al. (New York, USA), it was observed that majority of the teachers were ready to take responsibility of disseminating health information and undergo staff development programme for the same.16 We had similar observation with majority of teachers accepted the responsibility in adolescent health and were ready to undergo requisite training. Those undergone training had better involvement. This indicates that although overall attitude is good, but lack of training resulted in poor knowledge and intervention. Most of the teachers agreed to the need of inclusion of sex education and orientation to contraception in the curriculum. They also agreed to the need of professional managed health cell for students in every school. Teachers believed that their involvement in non-teaching work and lack of parents’ trust in them were important hurdles for any intervention.

CONCLUSION

Involvement of the teachers in adolescent health was low; teachers from urban area fared slightly better than rural counterparts. Teachers have good attitude and are ready to accept their responsibility in adolescent health. The teachers are interested in helping their students and are ready to take efforts for the same. However, they lack in proper knowledge and guidance regarding the issue. Their involvement can improve with proper training and encouragement.

Similarly, it is also advised to develop a health cell armed with professionals at every school.

The reduction of non-teaching or accessory work-load on the teachers by the school administration will help them in concentrating efforts towards adolescent health issues.

Teachers are in the position to help and mentor the adolescents. However, lack of parents’ trust in them proves to be an important hindrance for the teachers. It is recommended to increase the parent-teacher interactions as well as to orientation of parents to adolescent health.

A dynamic and socio-culturally relevant, periodic evaluation system for assessing the involvement of teachers in adolescent health is strongly recommended.

Limitations of the study

The study is based on self-administered questionnaires, hence reporting bias cannot be eliminated. There may be over estimation of positive attitude and good practices. There is no mechanism to confirm the findings.

Notes

[3] Conflicts of interest CONFLICTS OF INTEREST

None to declare.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

We would like to thank all the institutes and all the study participants for giving their valuable time and co-operation for this research.

REFERENCES

1. 

Webster’s New World College Dictionary. 4th. Role: edNew Delhi: Wiley – Dreamtech India Pvt Ltd; 2006. Adolescence; p. 18

2. 

Viner RM, Ozer EM, Denny S, Marmot M, Resnick M, Fatusi A, et al. , authors. Adolescence and the social determinants of health. Lancet. 2012;379(9826):1641–52

3. 

Nayar PD, Mehta R , authors. Public Health Impact of Adolescent Health and Development. Bhave SY , editor. Role: editorBhave’s Textbook of Adolescent Medicine New Delhi: Jaypee Brothers Medical Publishers (P) Ltd; 2006. p. 988–94

4. 

Sawyer SM, Afifi RA, Bearinger LH, Blakemore SJ, Dick B, Ezeh AC, Patton GC , authors. Adolescence: a foundation for future health. Lancet. 2012;379(9826):1630–40

5. 

Amdekar YK, Bhave SY , authors. Development of Adolescent Specialty in India – Historical Perspective. Bhave SY , editor. Role: editorBhave’s Textbook of Adolescent Medicine New Delhi: Jaypee Brothers Medical Publishers (P) Ltd; 2006. p. 4–7

6. 

Tylee A, Haller DM, Graham T, Churchill R, Sanci LA , authors. Youth-friendly primarycare services: how are we doing and what more needs to be done? Lancet. 2007;369(9572):1565–73

7. 

Sawyer SM, Afifi RA, Bearinger LH, Blakemore SJ, Dick B, Ezeh AC, Patton GC , authors. Adolescence: a foundation for future health. Lancet. 2012;379(9826):1630–40

8. 

Cohall AT, Cohall R, Dye B, Dini S, Vaughan RD, Coots S , authors. Overheard in the Halls: What Adolescents Are Saying, and What Teachers Are Hearing, About Health Issues. J Sch Health [Internet]. 2007;[cited 2016 Aug 29]. 77(7):344–50. Available from: http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1746-1561.2007.00218.x/.

9. 

Devgan S, Padda AS, Deepti SS, Kaur J, Ahlluwalia SK , authors. Effectiveness of health education among female teachers of senior secondary regarding problems in adolescence. Indian Journal of community health. 2012;24(2):107–12

10. 

American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders. 4. Role: ednText rev Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association; 2000

11. 

Shastri PC, Shastri JP , authors. Psychiatric disorders: Interview, assessment and diagnosis. Bhave SY , editor. Role: editorBhave’s Textbook of Adolescent Medicine New Delhi: Jaypee Brothers Medical Publishers (P) Ltd; 2006. p. 749–52

12. 

Greydanus DE, Yadav S , authors. Substance abuse disorders. Bhave SY , editor. Role: editorBhave’s Textbook of Adolescent Medicine New Delhi: Jaypee Brothers Medical Publishers (P) Ltd; 2006. p. 800–5

13. 

Jain T Bisht , author. Impact of Violence. Bhave SY , editor. Role: editorBhave’s Textbook of Adolescent Medicine New Delhi: Jaypee Brothers Medical Publishers (P) Ltd; 2006. p. 907–11

14. 

Shridevi kv , author. Awareness towards adolescent reproductive health among teacher trainees of Awassa, South Ethiopia. Review of Research [Internet]. 2012;[cited 2016 Aug 29]. 1:1–4. Available from: http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.300.6779&rep=rep1&type=pdf.

15. 

Waghachavare VB , author. Assessment of reproductive health, psychological and behavioural problems in late adolescents and role of teachers in dealing with it. [M.D. in Community Medicine]. Bharati Vidyapeeth Deemed University; Pune: 2014

16. 

Cohall A T, Cohall R, Dye B, Dini S, Vaughan R D, Coots S , authors. Overheard in the Halls: What Adolescents Are Saying, and What Teachers Are Hearing, About Health Issues. Journal of School Health [Internet]. 2007;[cited 2016 Aug 29]. 77(7):344–50. Available from: http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1746-1561.2007.00218.x/full.